The penalty shoot-out
The shoot-out is barely 56 years old. Before it, a drawn cup tie could be settled by a replay, or by drawing lots. This page covers how it came about, the moments that shaped it, and how our Penalty Shoot-out scenario turns it into a quiz.
The scenario
- You start
- 0-0, five kicks each, you go first
- Target
- Win the shoot-out
- Difficulty
- ★★, points ×1.3
- Questions
- Medium for the first three rounds, hard from the fourth
Each question is a kick. On your kicks, a perfect answer always scores; a close one goes in 45% of the time and otherwise hits the post or is saved; a scrappy one creeps in 15% of the time; wrong or too slow never scores. On their kicks you are the goalkeeper: a perfect answer always saves, a close one saves 30% of the time, and even after a scrappy answer they miss one in ten by themselves. As in a real shoot-out, it stops as soon as one side can't be caught, and if it is level after five each it goes to sudden death, a kick each at a time. In our simulations a player who gets about half their answers perfect wins 48% of the time.
Before the shoot-out: replays, toss-ups and lots
Until 1970 the Laws of the Game had no way of breaking a tie. Competitions used extra time, then replays or play-offs, and when a replay was impossible (at a tournament, say) they fell back on chance. At the 1968 European Championship, Italy reached the final by beating the Soviet Union on the drawing of lots after a goalless semi-final in Naples. The final itself, against Yugoslavia, was drawn and replayed two days later.
The same year, at the Olympic tournament in Mexico, Israel went out of the quarter-finals to Bulgaria on the drawing of lots. That is one of the two stories behind the shoot-out's invention.
Who invented it
Two people are credited, and the truth is uncertain.
- Karl Wald, a referee from Bavaria, is said to have used kicks from the penalty mark to settle games unofficially from the early 1960s. The Bavarian football association added it to its rules in May 1970.
- Yosef Dagan, an Israeli, is said to have proposed it after Israel's exit in 1968. His idea was described by Michael Almog in FIFA News in August 1969.
FIFA put the idea to the International Football Association Board, which looked at it in February 1970 and adopted it at its annual meeting on 27 June 1970.
The first one in England
The first shoot-out in English professional football came weeks later, on 5 August 1970, at Boothferry Park. It was a Watney Cup semi-final, a pre-season tournament, between Hull City and Manchester United, drawn 1-1. George Best took the first kick and scored. Denis Law took United's second and had it saved, the first miss. Hull's goalkeeper, Ian McKechnie, took his side's last kick and hit the bar, so United won and McKechnie became the first goalkeeper to miss one.
Panenka, 1976
The first major international tournament decided by a shoot-out was the 1976 European Championship. In the final in Belgrade, Czechoslovakia and West Germany drew 2-2. Czechoslovakia led 4-3 in the shoot-out when Antonín Panenka ran up for the fifth kick and, instead of striking it, chipped it softly down the middle as the goalkeeper, Sepp Maier, dived. Czechoslovakia won 5-3. A chipped penalty has been called a "Panenka" ever since.
At the World Cup
The first shoot-out at a World Cup finals was the 1982 semi-final in Seville between West Germany and France, a 3-3 draw after extra time. It went to sudden death, and West Germany won. The first World Cup final settled on penalties was in 1994 in Pasadena, when Brazil beat Italy 3-2 after a goalless draw.
England lost their first World Cup shoot-out, the 1990 semi-final against West Germany in Turin, and did not win one at a World Cup until they beat Colombia in Moscow in 2018.
The rules today
- A coin toss decides which goal is used, and a second toss decides who kicks first.
- Each side takes five kicks, each by a different player, alternately. It ends early once one side can't catch the other.
- If it is still level, sudden death follows: a kick each until one scores and the other doesn't.
- Only players on the pitch at the end of extra time can take part. If one side has more players, it reduces its number to match.
- Goalkeepers must stay on the goal line until the ball is kicked, though they may move along it. Since 2019 they need only part of one foot on, or level with, the line.
The ABBA experiment
Studies of real shoot-outs suggested that the side kicking first wins more often than not. In 2017 the IFAB tried a different order, borrowed from the tie-break in tennis: A, B, B, A, A, B and so on, so that neither side always kicks under more pressure. It was used at UEFA's under-17 championships that year and, in England, in the 2017 Community Shield between Arsenal and Chelsea, which Arsenal won on penalties. In November 2018 the IFAB decided not to continue with it, and the old order stayed.
Our scenario keeps the classic order, with you kicking first. It is the one part of the game where close is rarely good enough: on your own kicks, a close answer misses more often than it scores.
Sources
- Penalty shoot-out (association football), Wikipedia (origins, IFAB adoption, the first shoot-outs, current rules). Checked 11 November 2026.
- UEFA Euro 1976 final, Wikipedia.
- IFAB rules on time-wasting subs, handballs and penalty shoot-outs, Inside World Football, 23 November 2018 (the end of the ABBA trial).
- Law 14: the penalty kick, The IFAB (the goalkeeper's position).
Step up. The button opens the game with the Penalty Shoot-out ready to play.
TAKE THE SHOOT-OUTMore scenarios: Extra Time · Istanbul 2005 · all eight